Monday, April 04, 2005

Can an Incorrectly Calculated Guidelines Sentence Be Reasonable under Booker (or Vice-Versa)? Second Circuit Asks, but Does Not Answer, the Question

United States v. Rubenstein, Docket No. 03-1721 (2d Cir. March 31, 2005) (Cardamone, Jacobs, and Cabranes) (Op. by Jacobs):

Introduction: In this case, the Court rejects a legal challenge to the defendants' conviction for improperly removing asbestos under the Clean Air Act, but vacates their sentences because of an improperly imposed 4-level enhancement. In so doing, the Court "express[ed] no opinion as to whether an incorrectly calculated Guidelines sentence could nonetheless be reasonable" and thus affirmed on appeal regardless of the error, Opinion at 13, but chose to vacate the pre-Booker sentence anyway (rather than engage in Booker's reasonableness analysis) "because we think that the influence of this error is likely to be so pronounced that it could cause resentencing after remand to be unreasonable." Op. at 19.

In a concurrence, Judge Cardamone tantalizingly opines that "it is entirely possible that a correctly calculated Guidelines sentence might nonetheless be found unreasaonble upon consideration of other factors" listed under Section 3553(a), concurring Op. at 2 (emphasis added). He further suggests that in future cases where sentencing occurred after Booker, vacatur will not be automatic even where the Guidelines range was miscalculated because "[t]hose sentences will be reviewed for reasonableness, and [] an incorrectly calculated Guidelines sentence might nonetheless be reasonable . . . ." Id.

Discussion: The defendants -- a father and son -- are Hasidic Jews who "live in an insular religious community of Hasidic Jews." Op. at 3. They owned and operated a building in Brooklyn. After a third party signed a 49 year, $50 million lease for the building, the defendants began removing asbestos located throughout the building. They simply asked a few men who worked for them to do the removal and did not tell the workers that the material was asbestos. The workers removed the asbetos without any safety equipment and then improperly disposed of the asbestos.

At the defendants' trial for violating the Clean Air Act for improper removal of asbestos, 42 U.S.C. § 7413(c)(1), defense counsel asked the court to charge the jury that the defendants can be found guilty only if they were aware of the existence of regulations governing asbestos removal. The trial court rejected this request, since the Second Circuit has held that "the government need only prove that a defendant knew that the material being removed was asbestos" to sustain a conviction under this section (and need not prove that a defendant was aware of laws and regulations governing asbestos removal). Op. at 10 (discussing United States v. Weintraub, 273 F.3d 139, 151 (2d Cir. 2001)). The defendants nonetheless argued below and on appeal that because "they belong to an insular religious community of Hasidic Jews in which asbestos is not a subject of interest," there should be an exception to Weintraub for them. Op. at 10.

The Court quickly rejected this argument, holding that Weintraub's "presuppos[ition] [of] knowledge that asbestos is a regulated material" is not "a rebuttal presumption." Op. at 10-11. One violates § 7413(c)(1) if s/he removes asbestos improperly and knows that the material is asbestos, regardless of whether s/he is aware of the illegality of his or her own conduct. Alternatively, the Court looked to the facts of the case and ruled that even if some sort of good-faith defense were available, these particular defendants were not entitled to a charge to this effect because the evidence adduced at trial clearly showed that the Rubensteins were well aware that asbestos was a closely regulated substance. Op. at 11.

The Court vacated the defendants' sentences, however, after concluding that the district court improperly imposed a 4-level enhancement under § 2Q1.2(b)(4) (applicable if "the offense involved transportation, treatment, storage, or disposal" of a hazardous substance "without a permit or in violation of a permit"). The Court ruled that the enhancement was improper because the "offense" at issue -- the Clean Air Act -- did not require the defendants to obtain a permit for the disposal of asbestos. Op. at 18. It was irrelevant that New York State regulations required a permit for the transportation and disposal of asbestos, since the enhancement is triggered only where the "'offense involve[d]' activity in violation of a permit." Id.

What is more interesting than this substantive holding is the Court's discussion of why it decided to vacate the sentences rather than simply evaluate them for reasonableness, in accordance with Booker. (Of course, since the sentencing predated Booker, a remand would be required pursuant to Crosby in any event, but that's another story). Indeed, the Court specifically "express[ed] no opinion as to whether an incorrectly calculated Guidelines sentence could nonetheless be reasonable," which determination would obviate the need for vacatur and remand. Op. at 13. The Court decided to vacate the sentences in this case because it concluded that "the influence of [the erroneous imposition of the 4-level enhancement] is likely to be so pronounced that it could cause resentencing after remand to be unreasonable." Op. 19.

In a concurrence, Judge Cardamone criticized the majority for suggesting (at one point) that vacatur is somehow "necessary" -- rather than merely discretionary -- when the Guidelines range is miscalculated. Post-Booker, Judge Cardamone pointed out, a correctly calculated Guidelines range "is but one factor to be considered under 18 U.S.C. § 3553 in reviewing [the] reasonableness" of a sentence on appeal. Concurrence at 1. Thus, "it is entirely possible that a correctly calculated Guidelines sentence might nonetheless be found unreasonable upon consideration of other factors" under § 3553(a). Id. at 2. Conversely, "[b]y the same token, an incorrectly calculated Guidelines sentence might nonetheless be reasonable." Id. Judge Cardamone thus concluded that because sentences imposed after Booker "will be reviewed for reasonableness, and because an incorrectly calculated Guidelines sentence might nonetheless be reasonable, vacatur of a sentence based on Guidelines errors would not automatically be warranted." Id.

Comment: This case discusses, but does not settle, a critical question left open in the wake of Booker (and Crosby). That question is either (1) whether a sentence imposed upon an incorrectly calculated Guidelines range is necessarily unreasonable, or (conversely) (2) whether a sentence imposed upon a correctly calculated Guidelines range is necessarily reasonable. The majority opinion does not answer the question, but suggests that reasonableness review on appeal is not entirely dependent upon whether the Guidelines range was correctly calculated in the first place. Judge Cardamone's concurrence does indeed answer the question: A correctly calculated Guidelines range is but one factor to consider under reasonableness analysis, and thus a sentence could be upheld as reasonableness even where the Guidelines range was incorrectly calculated (and, conversely, a sentence could be vacated as unreasonable even where the Guidelines range was correctly calculated). The concurrence, however, is of course not binding on future panels.

32 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I give your blog an A+ with a Gold Star! I really enjoy your content and will be back very frequently! I enjoyed the information you had on asbestos as well. I actually have an asbestos blog with all kinds of cool things in it. May I put a link to this blog of yours on mine?

September 1, 2005 at 1:12 AM  
Blogger Pet Index 2 said...

I think you have a really good blog. I have one about mesothelioma attorney . please visit it and if your interested we could swap links

January 3, 2006 at 12:34 AM  
Blogger mesothelioma said...

Excellent blog. I have one about mesothelioma law . I think your visitors may be interested in mesothelioma law so please check it out.

January 3, 2006 at 12:35 AM  
Blogger Pet Index 2 said...

Excellent blog. I have one about mesothelioma cancer . I think your visitors may be interested in mesothelioma cancer so please check it out.

January 3, 2006 at 12:35 AM  
Blogger Pet Index 2 said...

Nice post. I have a blog which can be found at http://mesothelioma-treatment1.blogspot.com about mesothelioma

January 3, 2006 at 12:37 AM  
Anonymous Mesothelioma Lawyer Secrets said...

La conjecture I ne savent pas que autant au sujet du new jersey mesothelioma lawyer que je m'ai pens� .Candidly, Britteny new jersey mesothelioma lawyer

January 22, 2006 at 1:46 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have definitely made some mistakes in working this out, but all for the better.Best Wishes, Lizeth asbestos danger

January 25, 2006 at 4:47 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Congratulations Friend for your excellent blog on yahoo stock quotes!Keep up the good work!
If you have a moment, please visit my site:
yahoo stock quotes
I send you my warm regards and wish you continued success.
Have a nice day! :-)

February 11, 2006 at 5:30 AM  
Blogger Mesothelioma Resource said...

Hello there blogger, I've been reading through quite a few blogs on your subject and not many are as good as yours. You should be proud of your good work. Well done and keep it up.

Regards
Mesothelioma treatment Info

February 13, 2006 at 3:49 PM  
Anonymous mesothelioma lawyers said...

Hi, Thank you for having this info on the web. I enjoyed your post. If you may have any interest in
Massachusetts Lawyers then I know where you may get your solution. For your comfort, I have enclosed the link, so if needed you can visit the site. Thanks again for your lovely blog.

March 9, 2006 at 9:29 PM  
Anonymous mesothelioma said...

Hi, Thank you for having this info on the web. I enjoyed your post. If you may have any interest in
Massachusetts Lawyers then I know where you may get your solution. For your comfort, I have enclosed the link, so if needed you can visit the site. Thanks again for your lovely blog.

March 11, 2006 at 3:54 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have to admit i have not seen a perfectly made blog like u got here anywhere wanna exchange links ??

Take care
Ohio Mesothelioma Lawyer

March 17, 2006 at 9:11 PM  
Anonymous Rick J said...

I have been following a site now for almost 2 years and I have found it to be both reliable and profitable. They post daily and their stock trades have been beating
the indexes easily.

Take a look at Wallstreetwinnersonline.com

RickJ

April 7, 2006 at 6:22 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi, Thank you for having this info on the web. I enjoyed your post. If you may have any interest in
debt consolidation
then I know where you may get your solution. For your comfort, I have enclosed the link, so if needed you can visit the site. Thanks again for your lovely blog. credit

May 17, 2006 at 7:21 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Signature

June 25, 2006 at 10:51 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

http://www.mesothelioma-treatment.co.uk
malignant mesothelioma

July 1, 2006 at 5:09 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Comment

July 1, 2006 at 10:14 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

http://www.mesothelioma-treatment.co.uk
asbestos mesothelioma

July 2, 2006 at 7:35 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Signature

July 2, 2006 at 8:46 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

http://www.mesothelioma-treatment.co.uk
sacramento personal injury attorneys

July 2, 2006 at 11:04 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Comment

July 3, 2006 at 1:11 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

http://www.mesothelioma-treatment.co.uk
mesothilioma

July 5, 2006 at 5:27 AM  
Anonymous take over payments said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!
I have a take over payments site.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Greetings.

July 6, 2006 at 7:40 AM  
Anonymous stock reports said...

I was searching blogs,and I found yours.Please,
accept my congratulations for your excellent work!
If you have a moment, please visit my stock reports site.
Have a good day!

July 13, 2006 at 4:53 PM  
Blogger chxiao said...

Today Observationen News
Today Observationen TOP WebSite
Today Observationen HOT Auctions
Today Observationen Free Books
Today Observationen Free Music
Today Observationen HOT Electronics
Today Observationen E-products

October 4, 2006 at 12:01 AM  
Blogger Amin said...

Hi,

Your mesothelioma blog is impressive and useful to those who seek information on mesothelioma.

Thanks for sharing the info and articles.
Regards, Amy
Mesothelioma Lung Cancer
www.mesotheliomalungcancer.org

May 3, 2007 at 9:01 PM  
Blogger doron said...

here you can find Viagra the best solution for ED treatment ,
Viagra every 6 hours every day. Buy Viagra

yes or no Viagra

There are many online pharmacies were you can find

Viagra
online and prices will be much cheaper
, Generic Viagra more over you can always Viagra On the street, Viagrafor money to
Buy Viagra Online is the best.viagra no prescription

In adition you can use Cheap Viagra you can buy Cheap Viagra online yes now you can buy Cheap Viagraor you can look forCialis for the same and some times Buy Cialis a longer lasting result!

Cialis in fact is similar to viagra in it’s affect.
Cialis is one of the most effective meal
Buy Cialis Online enhancement medications online ! Buy Cialis Online with most online pharmacies. Buy Phentermine Online it is a worldwide known drug Buy Phentermine Online
can be found on the web on numerous locations.
Buy Phentermine Online

More over yes now Buy Phentermine Online is known for it’s results
Xanax Online
is an anti anxiety medication Xanax is a short-acting drug
Buy Xanax is used to treat anxiety Buy Xanax online. best online pharmacy for you.

Vicodin Online narcotic analgesic product

Buy Vicodin relieve moderate to severe pain
Viagra Alternative You can find Buy Vicodin and
Buy Valium to treat anxiety disorders. Ultram on sale Ultram best price Ultram cheap pharmacy Ambien best price Cialis online today Cialis is known for it’s results Valium online sale Valium online sale Buy Valium
today Buy Xanax Online cheap prices Buy Xanax online today.

August 1, 2010 at 4:42 AM  
Blogger doron said...

Many pepole use Ambien Online Today.
viagra no prescription the popular insomnia relief,
viagra without prescription also no you can buy Cialis without prescription
yes it is true Cialis without prescription

is now available Viagra Online
Find the most competitive online Ambien
Online Pharmacies Ambien lowest prices Viagra is a semi-synthetic opioid Buy Phentermine Online naturally occurring opiates Buy Hydrocodone can be found online Hydrocodone is very effective !

Hydrocodone is an FDA approved medication.

Oxycodone narcotic pain-reliever.

Oxycodone Online for sensation of pain.

Oxycodone should be stored between 15 to 30 C
Buy Oxycodone relief of moderate to severe pain.
Oxycontin tablets is 5 to 30 mg every 4 hours. Buy Oxycontin
narcotic pain-relievers Oxycontin may lead to increased Levitra is formulated as orange Phentermine cross debossed on one side
Ambien only for you Ativan here also Oxycontin best price Adderall online sale Loeazepam for you Hydrocodone for pain Hydrocodone on sale today Buy Hydrocodone Online here. Buy Cialis online today Buy Phentermine Online big sale Buy Phentermine in UK pharmacy Buy Cialis cheapest prices Buy Valium today Hydrocodone Online pharmacy Adipex best offers Ambien online pharmacy Meridia best offer Buy Meridia trusted source Meridia online options Meridia best pharmacy Lorazepam best offer Alprazolam best choice accutane online here.

August 1, 2010 at 4:57 AM  
Blogger doron said...

In some cases Viagrais the best solution
Viagra Alternativemany people use
Buy xanax
and other try Xanax
you can Buy xanaxand also try to use
Phentermine
yes many pepole try
Buy Phentermine Online
and many others use
Propecia
another drug you is
Cialis also called a hypnotic.
Cialis affects chemicals in your brain Buy Phentermine Online unbalanced and cause sleep problems
cialis that causes
cialis dose-related depression
Alprazolam
is useful in treating anxiety
cialis and muscle spasms
cialis Brand name is
Phentermine A generic version
Percocet is a combination of
viagra is a Schedule
Buy Percocet to discuss what
Phentermine These would include
Percocet recreationally rather than
Buy Phentermine Online either an Addict
Valium yes this is the best website for
Valium here you can purchase
Valium online without prescription,
Valium from USA pharmacy
Valium for Anxity, or
Buy Phentermine Online on how best to deal
Phentermine No prescription specifically developed to allow Phentermine No prescription for office-based treatment Buy Ativan is in a group of drugs
Ativan is used to treat anxiety disorders.
Klonopin is in a group of drugs called benzodiazepines
Xanax online offers
Xanax online sale
Ambien best price
Ambien best choice Ativan also here Ativan No Prescription Klonopin best price Xenical best prices Ultram online pharmacy Ambien Online best price.

August 1, 2010 at 5:01 AM  
Blogger doron said...

Clonazepam
affects chemicals Clonazepam is used to Klonopin if you Zolpidem prevents the Propecia use by men only Diazepam not be used cialis is pain reliever.
Cialis no prescription is the best.
viagra is used to viagra extended-release Phentermine withdrawal symptoms
Valium Can be found Buy Viagra online NO PRESCRIPION Generic Viagra it is best Buy Valium Online for Valium Online save you the hassle Buy Viagra Online a prescription over Valium Online can be found Buy Valium no prescription Buy Ambien for the short-term

Buy Levitra for the
Buy codeine narcotic pain-reliever .
codeine is morphine
codeine in the brain Acomplia new class Acomplia Cannabinoid-1 Phentermine Without Prescription online buy Xanax best prices Xanax worldwide delivery Xanax for the best Xanax at discount Xanax for anxity. Vicodin cheap prices Hydrocodone best solution Hydrocodone against pain Levitra online sale Tramadol online here Tramadol best prices Adipex online pharmacy Ambien right now
Ambien best prices Ambien best prices Buy Ambien Online discount pharmacy Buy Ambien save money Buy Adipex Online today Tramadol cheap online Vicodin online today Valium Online without prescription Cheap Cialis onlline today Cheap Cialis usa

August 1, 2010 at 5:08 AM  
Anonymous adobe acrobat x pro download said...

In this blog is very nice post.so great finance advise to them.

November 9, 2011 at 4:44 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

higher in the group of patients with ischaemic heart disease, diabetes, and cialis cialis price,cialis online cialis price, generic viagra cialis,viagra generic cialis
http://genericcialispricegnf.com#cialis pills http://cialisonlinepillsgkd.com#cialis http://genericviagraonlinejvrg.com#generic viagra http://buyviagraonlinertvr.com#buy viagra

March 31, 2013 at 4:38 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home