Tuesday, April 05, 2005

Deductive Logic Comes to the Second Circuit: The Meaning of an "Either/Or" Adjudication by a State Appellate Court for a Subsequent Habeas Petition

DeBerry v. Portuondo, Docket No. 03-2418 (2d Cir. April 4, 2005) (Walker, Oakes, and Pooler) (Opinion by Pooler) (Concurrence by Walker): In this case, the Second Circuit affirms the district court's denial of a § 2254 petition filed by a state prisoner claiming that the prosecutor violated the rule of Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79 (1986), in using his peremptory challenges to strike African-Americans from the jury at petitioner's murder trial. Readers interested in the Batson issue should read the opinion for themselves. This Blog will focus on another issue touched upon by this case: What is the effect on a subsequent habeas petition when the claim advanced in the habeas was originally rejected by a state appellate court simply as "either" unpreserved for appellate review "or" without merit?

This is an issue that has been kicking around for awhile in the Circuit, and there is clearly a tension between cases issued by different panels. DeBerry unfortunately does not resolve the dispute, which is highlighted by Chief Judge Walker's fascinating concurrence. A warning may be necessary at this point: This is seriously soporific stuff, likely of interest only to those concerned with habeas minutiae.

A very brief discussion of the facts is required. DeBerry and a co-defendant were convicted at trial of murder, and they appealed to the Appellate Division, raising among other things a Batson claim. The Appellate Division affirmed the convictions, stating with respect to the Batson claim only that it was "either unpreserved for appellate review (citing cases) or [] without merit." The New York Court of Appeals denied leave to appeal.

DeBerry subsequently filed a § 2254 petition in federal court, raising a Batson argument. After conducting a reconstruction hearing, the district court denied the petition.

Judge Pooler wrote for the Court and affirmed the lower court's dismissal of the habeas. In so doing, she made two interesting procedural determinations, both of which flow from the Appellate Division's terse "either / or" rejection of the Batson claim. First, Judge Pooler rejected the state's argument that the Batson claim was procedurally defaulted, concluding that there was no clear statement by the Appellate Division that it was rejecting this claim on the basis of New York's claim-preservation rule. Second, Judge Pooler concluded that AEDPA deference was not warranted on the Batson claim, because it was also not clear that the Appellate Division had adjudicated this claim "on the merits." In his concurrence, Judge Walker finds no fault with the first determination, but argues that the second conclusion is logically inconsistent with the first. Although this argument has surface appeal ("If the state court did not dismiss the claim on procedural grounds, it must have done so on the merits!"), it is ultimately wrong.

The first consequence of the Appellate Division's "either / or" adjudication for the habeas case creates little controversy: It means that the habeas court cannot conclude that the claim has been procedurally defaulted. As the Supreme Court has held, for a federal court to dispose of a habeas claim as procedurally defaulted, the state appellate court’s reliance on the independent state procedural bar must be "clear from the face of the opinion." Coleman v. Thompson, 501 U.S. 722, 735 (1991). In other words, "federal habeas review of a state court’s rejection of federal claims is allowed where the state has not ‘clearly and expressly state[d] that its judgment rests on a state procedural bar.’" Fama v. Commissioner, 235 F.3d 804, 809 (2d Cir. 2000), quoting Harris v. Reed, 489 U.S. 255, 263 (1989). Indeed, Fama -- cited by Judge Pooler on this very point -- specifically addressed the effect of the Appellate Division's terse "either / or" rulings: "[W]hen a state court uses language such as '[t]he defendant’s remaining contentions are either unpreserved for appellate review or without merit,' the validity of the claim is preserved and is subject to federal review." 235 F.3d at 809; see Reid v. Senkowski, 961 F.2d 374, 377 (2d Cir. 1992) (concluding that where the Appellate Division opined only that a claim was either unpreserved or meritless, "[t]he state court did not clearly and expressly state whether it had examined the merits of the missing witness claim or had relied on a procedural default . . . [and so the] claim is properly subject to federal habeas corpus review").

It is the second consequence of the Appellate Division's "either / or" ruling that generated the dispute between Judge Pooler and Judge Walker in this case -- its effect on AEDPA's deferential standard of review. Thus, after determining that a claim made in a habeas petition has not been procedurally defaulted, the habeas court must then determine whether AEDPA’s standard of review is applicable. As § 2254(d)(1) explicitly states, AEDPA's deferential standard (permitting a grant of habeas only where, inter alia, the state court's decision "involved an unreasonable application of clearly established federal law as determined by the Supreme Court) is triggered only when a claim had been "adjudicated on the merits in State court proceedings." If the claim had not been "adjudicated on the merits" by the state court, then no AEDPA deference is warranted and the habeas court will simply review the claim de novo.

In several cases, the Second Circuit has held that where it is impossible to discern from either the language of the state court opinion or from the record itself whether the court rejected the claim on procedural or merits-based grounds, "a federal court should not give AEDPA deference to the state appellate court’s ruling." Miranda v. Bennett, 322 F.3d 171, 178 (2d Cir. 2003). Indeed, Miranda specfically analyzed a claim rejected by the Appellate Division using the same, terse "either / or" language used in this case, and concluded that "[w]here it is 'impossible to discern the Appellate Division's conclusion on the [] issue,' a federal court should not give AEDPA deference to the state appellate court's ruling." Id. at 178. Miranda left open the possibility that in some cases, even where the Appellate Division employed its cryptic "either / or" language to reject the claim raised in the habeas petition, "the record [will] make[] it clear [] that a given claim had been properly preserved for appellate review." Id. In such cases, the habeas court should "conclude that it fell into the 'without merit' part of the disjunct even if it was not expressly discussed by the Appellate Division," id., and thus apply AEDPA deference in evaluating the habeas claim.

Relying on Miranda, Judge Pooler concluded that AEDPA deference was not warranted in this case because (1) the Appellate Division simply stated that the Batson claim was "either" procedurally defaulted "or" meritless, and (2) nothing in the record "makes it clear [] that [the Batson] claim had been properly preserved." Op. at 16-17. Unfortunately, Judge Pooler then went on to say that she did not need to resolve this issue, since the habeas petition was correctly dismissed using either the pre-AEDPA de novo standard or AEDPA's deferential standard, since there was no Batson violation. Op. at 18.

Judge Walker's concurrence focuses on Judge Pooler's conclusion that AEDPA deference was not applicable, and claims that this is logically inconsistent with her determination that the Batson claim was not procedurally defaulted. Judge Walker uses truth-function deductive logic to illustrate his argument, an effort that warms the heart of this former philosophy graduate student.

Judge Walker argues thus. Concurrence at 24. First, the Batson claim raised in the habeas petition was either (A) rejected on procedural grounds or (B) rejected on the merits, by the Appellate Division. Second, Judge Pooler's finding that the claim was not procedurally defaulted is tantamount to a finding of "not A". Q.E.D., the conclusion must be "B" -- i.e., the claim was rejected on the merits. And, therefore, AEDPA deference is warranted. [For those keeping score at home, this argument would be written as follows in standard truth function logic: Premise I: A v B; Premise II: ~A; Conclusion: B]. As Judge Walker puts it in plain English,

"The state court says its decision is based on either A (claim unpreserved) or B (fails on the merits). Fama creates a presumption that where the record provides no further indication of whether it was A or B, then the habeas court should presume it is not A (the claim is not unpreserved). Logic compels the conclusion that the state court must have decided the claim on the basis of B (the claim fails on the merits)."

Concurrence at 24. And, thus, AEDPA deference is warranted. Judge Walker cites to Ryan v. Miller, 303 F.3d 231 (2d Cir. 2003), for support. There, the Court broadly opined that if the claim was not procedurally defaulted, it must have been adjudicated on the merits for AEDPA purposes.

Clever as it is, the argument fails. The failure stems from a mis-statement of one of the premises. Specifically, while Judge Walker claims that Fama requires a habeas court confronted with an "either / or" ruling from the Appellate Division to "presume that . . . the claim is not unpreserved," this is not an accurate characterization. Rather, Fama simply applies Coleman's clear statement rule concerning procedural default: A habeas court should conclude that a claim has been procedurally defaulted only where the state court has "clearly and expressly state[d] that its judgment rests on a state procedural bar." Harris, 489 U.S. at 263. Thus, a conclusion that the Batson claim was not procedurally defaulted in the habeas proceeding is tantamount only to a determination that no clear statement demonstrates that the state court rejected this claim on procedural grounds. Such a conclusion is not equivalent to a finding that the state court in fact rejected the claim on the merits.

A similar "clear statement rule" governs whether AEDPA deference is triggered. As noted, the Second Circuit held in cases such as Miranda that where it is impossible to determine whether the state court adjucated the claim on the merits or on procedural grounds, AEDPA deference is not warranted. Thus, a conclusion that AEDPA deference is not warranted is not equivalent to a finding that the claim was in fact rejected on procedural grounds by the state court. Rather, it simply means that the state court did not clearly and expressly reject the claim on the merits.

That is the flaw in Judge Walker's seemingly airtight argument. While it is true that a habeas claim must have been (in some metaphysical sense) either (A) rejected on procedural grounds or (B) rejected on the merits by the state court, a conclusion that the claim is not procedurally defaulted in a subsequent habeas proceeding is not equivalent to a conclusion that the claim was in fact not rejected by the state court on procedural grounds. Rather, it is merely a finding that no clear statement exists demonstrating that the state court rejected the claim on procedural grounds. Conversely, when a habeas court rules that AEDPA deference is not warranted, this conclusion means only that no clear statement exists demonstrating that the state court rejected the claim on the merits; it does not mean that the claim was rejected on procedural grounds.

Looked at in this light, Judge Pooler's seemingly inconsistent conclusions are in fact perfectly consistent (and, dare we say, logical). Where no clear statement exists to demonstrate the basis of the state court's rejection of the habeas claim, the claim is not procedurally defaulted and AEDPA deference is not warranted.

41 Comments:

Blogger doron said...

here you can find Viagra the best solution for ED treatment ,
Viagra every 6 hours every day. Buy Viagra

yes or no Viagra

There are many online pharmacies were you can find

Viagra
online and prices will be much cheaper
, Generic Viagra more over you can always Viagra On the street, Viagrafor money to
Buy Viagra Online is the best.viagra no prescription

In adition you can use Cheap Viagra you can buy Cheap Viagra online yes now you can buy Cheap Viagraor you can look forCialis for the same and some times Buy Cialis a longer lasting result!

Cialis in fact is similar to viagra in it’s affect.
Cialis is one of the most effective meal
Buy Cialis Online enhancement medications online ! Buy Cialis Online with most online pharmacies. Buy Phentermine Online it is a worldwide known drug Buy Phentermine Online
can be found on the web on numerous locations.
Buy Phentermine Online

More over yes now Buy Phentermine Online is known for it’s results
Xanax Online
is an anti anxiety medication Xanax is a short-acting drug
Buy Xanax is used to treat anxiety Buy Xanax online. best online pharmacy for you.

Vicodin Online narcotic analgesic product

Buy Vicodin relieve moderate to severe pain
Viagra Alternative You can find Buy Vicodin and
Buy Valium to treat anxiety disorders. Ultram on sale Ultram best price Ultram cheap pharmacy Ambien best price Cialis online today Cialis is known for it’s results Valium online sale Valium online sale Buy Valium
today Buy Xanax Online cheap prices Buy Xanax online today.

August 1, 2010 at 4:41 AM  
Blogger doron said...

Many pepole use Ambien Online Today.
viagra no prescription the popular insomnia relief,
viagra without prescription also no you can buy Cialis without prescription
yes it is true Cialis without prescription

is now available Viagra Online
Find the most competitive online Ambien
Online Pharmacies Ambien lowest prices Viagra is a semi-synthetic opioid Buy Phentermine Online naturally occurring opiates Buy Hydrocodone can be found online Hydrocodone is very effective !

Hydrocodone is an FDA approved medication.

Oxycodone narcotic pain-reliever.

Oxycodone Online for sensation of pain.

Oxycodone should be stored between 15 to 30 C
Buy Oxycodone relief of moderate to severe pain.
Oxycontin tablets is 5 to 30 mg every 4 hours. Buy Oxycontin
narcotic pain-relievers Oxycontin may lead to increased Levitra is formulated as orange Phentermine cross debossed on one side
Ambien only for you Ativan here also Oxycontin best price Adderall online sale Loeazepam for you Hydrocodone for pain Hydrocodone on sale today Buy Hydrocodone Online here. Buy Cialis online today Buy Phentermine Online big sale Buy Phentermine in UK pharmacy Buy Cialis cheapest prices Buy Valium today Hydrocodone Online pharmacy Adipex best offers Ambien online pharmacy Meridia best offer Buy Meridia trusted source Meridia online options Meridia best pharmacy Lorazepam best offer Alprazolam best choice accutane online here.

August 1, 2010 at 4:56 AM  
Blogger doron said...

In some cases Viagrais the best solution
Viagra Alternativemany people use
Buy xanax
and other try Xanax
you can Buy xanaxand also try to use
Phentermine
yes many pepole try
Buy Phentermine Online
and many others use
Propecia
another drug you is
Cialis also called a hypnotic.
Cialis affects chemicals in your brain Buy Phentermine Online unbalanced and cause sleep problems
cialis that causes
cialis dose-related depression
Alprazolam
is useful in treating anxiety
cialis and muscle spasms
cialis Brand name is
Phentermine A generic version
Percocet is a combination of
viagra is a Schedule
Buy Percocet to discuss what
Phentermine These would include
Percocet recreationally rather than
Buy Phentermine Online either an Addict
Valium yes this is the best website for
Valium here you can purchase
Valium online without prescription,
Valium from USA pharmacy
Valium for Anxity, or
Buy Phentermine Online on how best to deal
Phentermine No prescription specifically developed to allow Phentermine No prescription for office-based treatment Buy Ativan is in a group of drugs
Ativan is used to treat anxiety disorders.
Klonopin is in a group of drugs called benzodiazepines
Xanax online offers
Xanax online sale
Ambien best price
Ambien best choice Ativan also here Ativan No Prescription Klonopin best price Xenical best prices Ultram online pharmacy Ambien Online best price.

August 1, 2010 at 5:00 AM  
Blogger doron said...

Clonazepam
affects chemicals Clonazepam is used to Klonopin if you Zolpidem prevents the Propecia use by men only Diazepam not be used cialis is pain reliever.
Cialis no prescription is the best.
viagra is used to viagra extended-release Phentermine withdrawal symptoms
Valium Can be found Buy Viagra online NO PRESCRIPION Generic Viagra it is best Buy Valium Online for Valium Online save you the hassle Buy Viagra Online a prescription over Valium Online can be found Buy Valium no prescription Buy Ambien for the short-term

Buy Levitra for the
Buy codeine narcotic pain-reliever .
codeine is morphine
codeine in the brain Acomplia new class Acomplia Cannabinoid-1 Phentermine Without Prescription online buy Xanax best prices Xanax worldwide delivery Xanax for the best Xanax at discount Xanax for anxity. Vicodin cheap prices Hydrocodone best solution Hydrocodone against pain Levitra online sale Tramadol online here Tramadol best prices Adipex online pharmacy Ambien right now
Ambien best prices Ambien best prices Buy Ambien Online discount pharmacy Buy Ambien save money Buy Adipex Online today Tramadol cheap online Vicodin online today Valium Online without prescription Cheap Cialis onlline today Cheap Cialis usa

August 1, 2010 at 5:03 AM  
Anonymous adobe acrobat x pro download said...

This is a very nice post..

November 9, 2011 at 4:20 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Cialis[url=http://www.cialis.ms]Cialis[/url]http://www.cialis.ms
Buy Xanax [url=http://www.xanax.ms] Xanax Online[/url]http://www.xanax.ms
Viagra Online Without Prescription[url=http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url]http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz
Cialis Without Prescription[url=http://www.cialiswithoutprescription.name] Cialis Without Prescription[/url]http://www.cialiswithoutprescription.name
Klonopin[url=http://www.klonopin.name]Klonopin [/url]http://www.klonopin.name

November 19, 2012 at 11:58 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Generic Viagra[url=http://www.viagra-generic.us] Generic Viagra[/url]http://www.viagra-generic.us
Cialis Without Prescription[url=http://www.cialis-without-prescription.name] Cialis Without Prescription[/url]http://www.cialis-without-prescription.name
Buy Cialis Online [url=http://www.cialis.gd] Cialis Online[/url]http://www.cialis.gd
Ambien [url=http://www.order-ambien.us]Ambien [/url]http://www.order-ambien.us

November 26, 2012 at 5:47 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Adipex [url=http://www.adipexpricer.com] Adipex Price[/url]http://www.adipexpricer.com

November 26, 2012 at 6:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Buy Xanax [url=http://www.xanaxusapharmacy.com] Xanax Online[/url]http://www.xanaxusapharmacy.com
Buy Adderall [url=http://www.adderallnorx.com]Adderall [/url]http://www.adderallnorx.com
phentermine [url=http://www.adipexbuy.us] Buy Adipex[/url]http://www.adipexbuy.us
Purchase Xanax[url=http://www.purchasexanax.us] Purchase Xanax[/url]http://www.purchasexanax.us

November 26, 2012 at 7:59 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


ambien[url=http://www.noiraqescalation.org]ambien[/url]http://www.noiraqescalation.org
Cialis[url=http://www.cialis.ms]Cialis[/url]http://www.cialis.ms
Viagra Online Without Prescription[url=http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.org]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url]http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.org
Ativan[url=http://www.ativan.name]Ativan[/url]http://www.ativan.name

December 5, 2012 at 2:17 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


xanax, xanax,

http://stats.samimattila.com/index.php?title=Prescription-Pill-Slang-Every-Parent-Should-Know

xanax, xanax,

http://sonicworldrunner.angelxwind.net/wiki/index.php?title=Wondering-How-Does-Xanax-Work?

xanax, xanax,

http://wearemudlark.com/derby2061/index.php?title=Prescription-Pill-Slang-Every-Parent-Should-Know

xanax, xanax,

http://wiki.fonacier.net/index.php?title=Wondering-How-Does-Xanax-Work?

xanax, xanax,

http://wiki.sampdb.com/index.php?title=The-Truth-About-Xanax-Side-Effects

December 6, 2012 at 12:08 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


valium, valium,

http://www.iamsport.org/pg/blog/georgemeter55/read/12629134/allowing-discomfort-the-secret-to-successful-recovery-from-addictive-behaviours

valium, valium,

http://bonefarm00.posterous.com/im-addicted-to-prescription-drugs-scientists

valium, valium,

http://www.zootoo.com/profile/enemydoctor02/blog/entry/allowingdiscomfortthesecrettos6

valium, valium,

http://www.lagbook.com/blogs/3176059

valium, valium,

http://www.purevolume.com/drawcrib85/posts/3034361/Side+Effects+of+Anti+Anxiety+Drugs

December 6, 2012 at 12:26 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


viagra, [url=http://rivally.com/pligg/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-133]viagra[/url],

http://rivally.com/pligg/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-133

viagra, [url=http://necology.jp/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-122]viagra[/url],

http://necology.jp/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-122

viagra, [url=http://therightfeed.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-151]viagra[/url],

http://therightfeed.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-151

viagra, [url=http://www.79up.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-63]viagra[/url],

http://www.79up.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-63

viagra, [url=http://www.burdasin.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-73]viagra[/url],

http://www.burdasin.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-73

January 3, 2013 at 3:39 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


viagra, [url=http://www.lagbook.com/blogs/3474059]viagra[/url],

http://www.lagbook.com/blogs/3474059

viagra, [url=http://www.purevolume.com/cellarquilt2/posts/3254834/Viagra+Online+Without+Prescription]viagra[/url],

http://www.purevolume.com/cellarquilt2/posts/3254834/Viagra+Online+Without+Prescription

viagra, [url=http://chequeskill8.posterous.com/viagra-online-without-prescription]viagra[/url],

http://chequeskill8.posterous.com/viagra-online-without-prescription

viagra, [url=http://wristquilt7.xanga.com/770327513/viagra-online-without-prescription/]viagra[/url],

http://wristquilt7.xanga.com/770327513/viagra-online-without-prescription/

viagra, [url=http://www.dipity.com/reasondibble3/Viagra_1]viagra[/url],

http://www.dipity.com/reasondibble3/Viagra_1

January 3, 2013 at 5:48 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Buy Viagra Online [url=http://www.buy-viagra-online.info] viagra online [/url]http://www.buy-viagra-online.info

Closeing Spinn ----->

January 10, 2013 at 7:55 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Viagra Online Without Prescription ggg [url=http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url] 778856 http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz ggfgdd
Cialis fhgfg [url=http://www.cialis.gd]Cialis sfsd [/url]http://www.cialis.gd
sdfsd Viagra gdggd [url=http://www.viagra-no-prescription.com]Viagra[/url] dfdsf http://www.viagra-no-prescription.com
dada Viagra fgf [url=http://www.viagra.gd]Viagra[/url] fsd http://www.viagra.gd
sdad Cialis Online ghjg [url=http://www.cialisonline-usa.com]Cialis Online[/url] 75676 http://www.cialisonline-usa.com

March 4, 2013 at 4:10 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Viagra Online Without Prescription ggg [url=http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url] 778856 http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz ggfgdd
Cialis fhgfg [url=http://www.cialis.gd]Cialis sfsd [/url]http://www.cialis.gd
sdfsd Viagra gdggd [url=http://www.viagra-no-prescription.com]Viagra[/url] dfdsf http://www.viagra-no-prescription.com
dada viagra online without prescription fgf [url=http://www.viagra.gd]Viagra[/url] fsd http://www.viagra.gd
sdad Cialis Online ghjg [url=http://www.cialisonline-usa.com]Cialis Online[/url] 75676 http://www.cialisonline-usa.com

March 4, 2013 at 6:04 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

&&& Viagra Online Without Prescription %%% [url=http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url] 778856 http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz ((()0
Cialis &&&& [url=http://www.cialis.gd]Cialis[/url] %%% http://www.cialis.gd (()) Viagra **&& [url=http://www.viagra-no-prescription.com]Viagra[/url] %%% http://www.viagra-no-prescription.com
(()) viagra online without prescription **** [url=http://www.viagra.gd]viagra online without prescription[/url] %%% http://www.viagra.gd
$$%% Cialis Online (()) [url=http://www.cialisonline-usa.com]Cialis Online[/url] +++ http://www.cialisonline-usa.com

March 13, 2013 at 11:17 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

&&& Viagra Online Without Prescription %%% [url=http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url] 778856 http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz ((()0
Cialis &&&& [url=http://www.cialis.gd]Cialis[/url] %%% http://www.cialis.gd (()) Viagra **&& [url=http://www.viagra-no-prescription.com]Viagra[/url] %%% http://www.viagra-no-prescription.com
(()) Viagra **** [url=http://www.viagra.gd]viagra online without prescription[/url] %%% http://www.viagra.gd
$$%% Cialis Online (()) [url=http://www.cialisonline-usa.com]Cialis Online[/url] +++ http://www.cialisonline-usa.com

March 22, 2013 at 10:32 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Klonopin[url=http://www.klonopin.name]Klonopin[/url]http://www.klonopin.name
viagra[url=http://www.viagrawithoutprescription.ws] viagra[/url]http://www.viagrawithoutprescription.ws
Cialis[url=http://www.cialis.gd]Cialis[/url]http://www.cialis.gd
Viagra Online Without Prescription[url=http://www.viagraonlinewithoutprescription.us]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url]http://www.viagraonlinewithoutprescription.us

April 7, 2013 at 7:42 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Adipex [url=http://www.buyadipexguide.com] Buy Adipex[/url]http://www.buyadipexguide.com
Viagra Online Without Prescription[url=http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.org]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url]http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.org
Viagra Online Without Prescription[url=http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url]http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz
Cialis[url=http://www.cialisonline-usa.com] buy cialis [/url]http://www.cialisonline-usa.com

April 8, 2013 at 5:36 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Viagra[url=http://www.viagra.gd]Viagra[/url]http://www.viagra.gd
Buy Klonopin[url=http://www.buy-klonopin.biz]Klonopin [/url]http://www.buy-klonopin.biz

April 8, 2013 at 6:01 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Viagra[url=http://www.viagra.gd]Viagra[/url]http://www.viagra.gd
Buy Cialis [url=http://www.cialisbuy.us] Cialis Online [/url]http://www.cialisbuy.us
Viagra Without Prescription [url=http://www.viagrawithoutprescription.vc] viagra[/url]http://www.viagrawithoutprescription.vc
Cialis Without Prescription [url=http://www.cialis-without-prescription.us]Cialis Without Prescription [/url]http://www.cialis-without-prescription.us

April 8, 2013 at 6:51 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Viagra[url=http://www.viagra.gd]Viagra[/url]http://www.viagra.gd
Cialis [url=http://www.cheap-cialis.name] Cheap Cialis[/url]http://www.cheap-cialis.name

Closeing Spinn ----->

April 18, 2013 at 4:22 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


buy phentermine [url=http://www.buyadipexguide.com] Buy Adipex Online [/url]http://www.buyadipexguide.com
Viagra Online Without Prescription[url=http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.org]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url]http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.org
Viagra Online Without Prescription[url=http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url]http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz
Cialis Online [url=http://www.cialisonline-usa.com] Cialis[/url]http://www.cialisonline-usa.com

April 18, 2013 at 4:51 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Viagra[url=http://www.viagra.gd]Viagra[/url]http://www.viagra.gd
Cialis Online Without Prescription [url=http://www.cialisonlinewithoutprescription.com]Cialis Online Without Prescription [/url]http://www.cialisonlinewithoutprescription.com

April 18, 2013 at 6:31 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Klonopin[url=http://www.klonopin.name]Klonopin[/url]http://www.klonopin.name
viagra[url=http://www.viagrawithoutprescription.ws] viagra[/url]http://www.viagrawithoutprescription.ws
Cialis[url=http://www.cialis.gd]Cialis[/url]http://www.cialis.gd
Viagra Online Without Prescription[url=http://www.viagraonlinewithoutprescription.us]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url]http://www.viagraonlinewithoutprescription.us

April 19, 2013 at 1:35 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Viagra[url=http://www.viagra-no-prescription.com]Viagra[/url]http://www.viagra-no-prescription.com
Buy Ativan[url=http://www.buyativanusa.com] Buy Ativan[/url]http://www.buyativanusa.com
Ativan [url=http://www.buyativan.us] Buy Ativan[/url]http://www.buyativan.us
Viagra[url=http://www.viagra.gd]Viagra[/url]http://www.viagra.gd

April 19, 2013 at 2:02 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Klonopin[url=http://www.klonopin.name]Klonopin[/url]http://www.klonopin.name
viagra[url=http://www.viagrawithoutprescription.ws]Viagra Without Prescription [/url]http://www.viagrawithoutprescription.ws
Cialis[url=http://www.cialis.gd]Cialis[/url]http://www.cialis.gd
Viagra Online Without Prescription[url=http://www.viagraonlinewithoutprescription.us]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url]http://www.viagraonlinewithoutprescription.us

April 19, 2013 at 2:55 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Viagra[url=http://www.viagra-no-prescription.com]Viagra[/url]http://www.viagra-no-prescription.com
Buy Ativan[url=http://www.buyativanusa.com] Buy Ativan[/url]http://www.buyativanusa.com
Buy Ativan[url=http://www.buyativan.us]Ativan [/url]http://www.buyativan.us
Viagra[url=http://www.viagra.gd]Viagra[/url]http://www.viagra.gd

April 21, 2013 at 11:11 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


buy phentermine [url=http://www.buyadipexguide.com] buy phentermine [/url]http://www.buyadipexguide.com
Viagra Online Without Prescription[url=http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.org]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url]http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.org
Viagra Online Without Prescription[url=http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz]Viagra Online Without Prescription[/url]http://www.viagra-online-without-prescription.biz
buy cialis online [url=http://www.cialisonline-usa.com]Cialis Online [/url]http://www.cialisonline-usa.com

April 22, 2013 at 1:07 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Define Batch Size: Select Environment Exctract: Clear! Enter Links Here, *** Without HTTP://WWW.***
Xrumer :: Full!
http://www.subhraseo.page.tl/best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online.htm Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.subhraseo.page.tl/best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online.htm] viagra[/url] asda
http://www.pantsvoyage7.exteen.com/20130513/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online viagra asd [url=http://www.pantsvoyage7.exteen.com/20130513/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online] viagra Online [/url] asda

May 14, 2013 at 7:02 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Define Batch Size: Select Environment Exctract: Clear! Enter Links Here, *** Without HTTP://WWW.***
Xrumer :: Full!
http://www.dropjacks.info/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription viagra asd [url=http://www.dropjacks.info/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription] viagra Online [/url] asda
http://www.directoryth.com/story/39692/ Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.directoryth.com/story/39692/] viagra [/url]asda
http://www.pantsfact2.xanga.com/773199850/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online/ viagra asd [url=http://www.pantsfact2.xanga.com/773199850/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online/] viagra [/url] asda
http://www.nexopia.com/users/kittenjury7/blog/5-buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.nexopia.com/users/kittenjury7/blog/5-buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online] Buy viagra[/url] asda
http://www.latincrossword.com/technology/viagra-online-without-prescription/ viagra asd [url=http://www.latincrossword.com/technology/viagra-online-without-prescription/] viagra[/url] asda
http://www.adamjones002.tumblr.com/post/50321691741/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.adamjones002.tumblr.com/post/50321691741/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online] viagra [/url] asda
http://www.akpermuhkendal.com/alumni/alumni/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription viagra Online asd [url=http://www.akpermuhkendal.com/alumni/alumni/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription] Buy viagra[/url] asda
http://www.cowman801.soup.io/post/312863364/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap viagra asd [url=http://www.cowman801.soup.io/post/312863364/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap] viagra [/url] asda
http://www.purevolume.com/pantswax8/posts/4217221/buying+viagra%3a+best+tips+to+buy+cheap+viagra+online viagra asd [url=http://www.purevolume.com/pantswax8/posts/4217221/buying+viagra%3a+best+tips+to+buy+cheap+viagra+online] Buy viagra[/url] asda
http://www.1-resources.com/news/viagra-online-without-prescription/ viagra asd [url=http://www.1-resources.com/news/viagra-online-without-prescription/] viagra[/url] asda

3

May 15, 2013 at 2:12 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Define Batch Size: Select Environment Exctract: Clear! Enter Links Here, *** Without HTTP://WWW.***
Xrumer :: Full!
http://www.kral.im/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription viagra asd [url=http://www.kral.im/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription] viagra Online [/url] asda
http://www.blogpost.biz/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription viagra asd [url=http://www.blogpost.biz/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription] viagra [/url] asda
http://www.cherishd.com/pligg/pligg/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription viagra Online asd [url=http://www.cherishd.com/pligg/pligg/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription] viagra Online [/url] asda
http://www.eyeuser.com/blogs/viewstory/1669020 viagra asd [url=http://www.eyeuser.com/blogs/viewstory/1669020] viagra [/url]asda
http://www.deadarmy.snappages.com/blog/2013/05/13/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online viagra asd [url=http://www.deadarmy.snappages.com/blog/2013/05/13/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online] viagra[/url] asda
http://www.esocialbookmarks.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription viagra Online asd [url=http://www.esocialbookmarks.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription] viagra Online [/url] asda
http://www.rockbabay90.dinstudio.com/11/4/20/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online/ Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.rockbabay90.dinstudio.com/11/4/20/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online/] Buy viagra[/url] asda
http://www.www.diigo.com/item/note/14t60/2j7o viagra asd [url=http://www.www.diigo.com/item/note/14t60/2j7o] viagra [/url]asda
http://www.blog.mn/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-4 viagra asd [url=http://www.blog.mn/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-4] viagra [/url] asda

4

May 15, 2013 at 8:32 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Define Batch Size: Select Environment Exctract: Clear! Enter Links Here, *** Without HTTP://WWW.***
Xrumer :: Full!
http://www.subhraseo.edublogs.org/2013/05/13/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online-3/ Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.subhraseo.edublogs.org/2013/05/13/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online-3/] viagra[/url] asda
http://www.meonlyme90.blogspot.in/2013/05/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap.html viagra Online asd [url=http://www.meonlyme90.blogspot.in/2013/05/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap.html] viagra[/url] asda
http://www.socialbookmarking.omgimow.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-80 viagra asd [url=http://www.socialbookmarking.omgimow.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription-80] viagra Online [/url] asda
http://www.twitter.com/koushik_may90/status/333812526804525056 viagra Online asd [url=http://www.twitter.com/koushik_may90/status/333812526804525056] viagra [/url]asda
http://www.antbook.eu/story/128172/ viagra asd [url=http://www.antbook.eu/story/128172/] viagra Online [/url]asda
http://www.blog.my/berita/viagra-online-without-prescription/ Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.blog.my/berita/viagra-online-without-prescription/] viagra[/url] asda
http://www.vzaonline.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription viagra asd [url=http://www.vzaonline.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription] Buy viagra[/url] asda
http://www.postolia.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.postolia.com/story.php?title=viagra-online-without-prescription] viagra Online [/url] asda
http://www.viagraonline33.webs.com/ Viagra online asd [url=http://www.viagraonline33.webs.com/] Buy viagra[/url] asda

7

May 15, 2013 at 10:04 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

http://www.babay.newsvine.com/_news/2013/05/15/18284827-buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online viagra asd [url=http://www.babay.newsvine.com/_news/2013/05/15/18284827-buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online] viagra[/url] asda
http://www.en.netlog.com/adamjones002/blog/blogid=23447589 Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.en.netlog.com/adamjones002/blog/blogid=23447589]viagra [/url]asda
http://www.cowman801.soup.io/post/312863364/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.cowman801.soup.io/post/312863364/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap] Buy viagra[/url] asda
http://www.sic9par.dhpreview.devhub.com/blog/1852871-buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online/ Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.sic9par.dhpreview.devhub.com/blog/1852871-buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online/] viagra [/url] asda
http://www.pantsvoyage7.exteen.com/20130513/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online viagra Online asd [url=http://www.pantsvoyage7.exteen.com/20130513/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online] viagra Online [/url] asda
http://www.myspace.com/592723716/blog/546911041 Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.myspace.com/592723716/blog/546911041] viagra Online [/url]asda
http://www.purevolume.com/pantswax8/posts/4217221/buying+viagra%3a+best+tips+to+buy+cheap+viagra+online Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.purevolume.com/pantswax8/posts/4217221/buying+viagra%3a+best+tips+to+buy+cheap+viagra+online] Buy viagra[/url] asda
http://www.babay.newsvine.com/_news/2013/05/13/18218548-buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online viagra asd [url=http://www.babay.newsvine.com/_news/2013/05/13/18218548-buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online] viagra [/url] asda
http://www.meonlyme90.blogspot.in/2013/05/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap.html viagra Online asd [url=http://www.meonlyme90.blogspot.in/2013/05/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap.html] viagra[/url] asda

2

May 18, 2013 at 10:20 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

http://www.diigo.com/item/note/14t60/2j7o viagra asd [url=http://www.diigo.com/item/note/14t60/2j7o]viagra [/url]asda
http://www.deadarmy.snappages.com/blog/2013/05/13/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online Buy viagra asd [url=http://www.deadarmy.snappages.com/blog/2013/05/13/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online] viagra [/url] asda
http://www.viagra330.blinkweb.com/ viagra asd [url=http://www.viagra330.blinkweb.com/] Buy viagra[/url] asda
http://www.kittenwax4.jigsy.com/entries/general/buying-viagra:-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online viagra asd [url=http://www.kittenwax4.jigsy.com/entries/general/buying-viagra:-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online] Buy viagra[/url] asda
http://www.throneerror7.wordpress.com/2013/05/13/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online/ viagra Online asd [url=http://www.throneerror7.wordpress.com/2013/05/13/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online/] viagra [/url] asda
http://www.brianbowl1.xanga.com/773261152/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online/ viagra Online asd [url=http://www.brianbowl1.xanga.com/773261152/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online/] viagra [/url] asda
http://www.l792qef.dhpreview.devhub.com/blog/1841941-buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online/ viagra Online asd [url=http://www.l792qef.dhpreview.devhub.com/blog/1841941-buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online/] viagra Online [/url] asda
http://www.theadventure88.blog.fc2.com/blog-entry-1207.html viagra asd [url=http://www.theadventure88.blog.fc2.com/blog-entry-1207.html] viagra Online [/url]asda
http://www.viagraonline33.webs.com/ viagra Online asd [url=http://www.viagraonline33.webs.com/] Buy viagra[/url] asda
http://www.adamjones002.tumblr.com/post/50550815980/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online viagra asd [url=http://www.adamjones002.tumblr.com/post/50550815980/buying-viagra-best-tips-to-buy-cheap-viagra-online] Buy viagra[/url] asda

3

May 18, 2013 at 10:32 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

<----- Opening Spinn
viagra, [url=http://ccdb-portal.crbs.ucsd.edu/web/richardsmith/advantages-of-the-blue-pill]viagra[/url], http://ccdb-portal.crbs.ucsd.edu/web/richardsmith/advantages-of-the-blue-pill

viagra, [url=http://ets.tlt.psu.edu/learningdesign/user/1169]viagra[/url],

http://ets.tlt.psu.edu/learningdesign/user/1169

viagra, [url=https://moodle.umn.edu/blog/index.php?postid=13080]viagra[/url],

https://moodle.umn.edu/blog/index.php?postid=13080

viagra, [url=https://students.washington.edu/elsafund/wp/wordpress/groups/advantages-of-the-blue-pill/]viagra[/url],

https://students.washington.edu/elsafund/wp/wordpress/groups/advantages-of-the-blue-pill/

viagra, [url=http://pocketknowledge.tc.columbia.edu/home.php/browse/90628]viagra[/url],

http://pocketknowledge.tc.columbia.edu/home.php/browse/90628

viagra, [url=http://100.jrn.msu.edu/groups/advantages-of-the-blue-pill/]viagra[/url],

May 20, 2013 at 2:27 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


http://moodle.obu.edu/mahara/view/view.php?id=1092

viagra, [url=http://moodle.mspp.edu/mahara/view/view.php?id=606]viagra[/url],

http://moodle.mspp.edu/mahara/view/view.php?id=606

viagra, [url=http://aluniversity.edu/elearning/blog/index.php?userid=28074]viagra[/url],

http://aluniversity.edu/elearning/blog/index.php?userid=28074

viagra, [url=http://moodle.perelandra.edu/moodle/blog/index.php?postid=51291]viagra[/url],

http://moodle.perelandra.edu/moodle/blog/index.php?postid=51291


May 22, 2013 at 12:16 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

[url=http://test1517.org]test1517.org[/url]
test1517.org
http://test1517.org

May 29, 2013 at 8:22 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


3##$$ Cialis ^^&& [url=http://www.cialis.gd]Cialis sfsd [/url]http://www.cialis.gd **//
(()) viagra online without prescription *&&^ [url=http://www.viagra.gd]Viagra[/url] **//* http://www.viagra.gd (())g

June 11, 2013 at 9:09 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home