Saturday, November 14, 2009

The Things We Do For Love

United States v. Caraballo, No. 08-4640-cr (2d Cir. November 5, 2009) (Leval, Raggi, Livingston, CJJ)

Gilberto Caraballo was a large-scale drug supplier in the Sunset Park section of Brooklyn. In September of 2000, he started dating Quincy Martinez, former girlfriend of Jose Fernandez, a dealer who worked for Caraballo. Three months into their relationship, Martinez asked Caraballo to murder Fernandez because he had been abusive toward her. Caraballo answered, “Say no more.”

Caraballo recruited one of his former drug dealers, Aguilar, and Aguilar’s associate, Taylor, to help do the job. Caraballo had previously cut off Aguilar’s supply over an unpaid drug debt, but promised to forgive the debt and resume supplying to him in exchange for the hit. Taylor, who realized that his own sales would increase once Caraballo started supplying Aguilar again, agreed to help and was to receive $5,000 in cash or drugs.

Aguilar, Taylor and Caraballo did the deed and, as promised, Caraballo gave Taylor cocaine and ecstacy pills, forgave Aguilar’s drug debt and arranged for both of them to begin receiving drugs on consignment. As a result of this arrangement, Caraballo was convicted of violating 21 U.S.C. § 848(e)(1)(A), which makes it a crime for “any person engaging in” a specified drug crime to kill or solicit a killing.

On appeal, although he conceded that the evidence supported his conviction for the predicate drug offense, Caraballo argued that the evidence was insufficient to support a finding that he committed the murder while “engaging in” the drug conspiracy.

The circuit affirmed. It first noted that the statutory language - “engaging in” - would seem to require only a temporal connection between the murder and the drug crime. But the Second Circuit, like every other court, has concluded that the government must prove a “substantive, and not merely temporal, connection” between the murder and the drug predicate. This requirement saves the statute from a possible Commerce Clause challenge and furthers the law’s purpose, which is to “target drug-related killings.”

Previously, the court has held that the “engaging in” element is satisfied by proof that there was a drug-related motive for the killing, although the court has made clear that it does not have to be the “primary” motive, or even of equal importance to any non-drug-related motive. But here, the court rejected Caraballo’s argument that these precedents required that the government prove that the killing was, at least in part, in furtherance of the drug crime.

Rather, the court explained, those precedents are simply illustrations of one type of substantive connection; they do not hold that proof of a drug-related motive is the only way to establish it. Nor is there any legitimate policy reason for limiting the scope of the statute to cover only killings that are specifically motivated by the predicate drug crime.

With that as a background, the court had little trouble finding the evidence sufficient here. “[W]e see no reason why [the substantive connection] is not also proved by evidence that the defendant used qualified drug dealings to procure the murder.” Thus, here, while the motive for the killing - Caraballo’s romantic relationship with Martinez - was not drug-related, using the drug conspiracy’s proceeds as a tool to procure the killing was “sufficient to permit a reasonable jury to find that Caraballo killed Fernandez while ‘engaging in’ the charged drug conspiracy.”

In a footnote, however, the court reiterated its view - still dicta, since it has not yet come up - that a drug dealer who killed a spouse in a purely non-drug-related domestic dispute would not satisfy the “engaging in” requirement of § 848(e)(1)(A).

Labels: ,


Anonymous Anonymous said...

Quincy has already been released from prison and ironically she just had a A baby boy she named ethan last week (dec 2009).hope things work out better for this guy she is with now.

December 23, 2009 at 12:22 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Quincy was a good girl who suffered alot of abuse at the hands of a man who said he loved her. I pray for her and if she did get out jail I pray that she is okay and if she is with someone now and has had a child. I pray that this guy think twice before ever putting his hands on quincy.

January 14, 2013 at 10:01 PM  
Blogger oakleyses said...

oakley sunglasses cheap, coach outlet store online, kate spade outlet, air max pas cher, louboutin outlet, louis vuitton outlet stores, longchamp handbags, christian louboutin shoes, prada outlet, burberry outlet, ray ban sunglasses, air max, coach factory outlet, tiffany and co, prada handbags, michael kors outlet, tory burch outlet, kate spade handbags, polo ralph lauren outlet, louis vuitton handbags, burberry outlet, michael kors outlet, true religion outlet, louis vuitton outlet, louis vuitton, michael kors outlet, louboutin, chanel handbags, michael kors outlet, louboutin shoes, michael kors outlet, longchamp handbags, longchamp outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet, nike shoes, tiffany and co, coach outlet, true religion jeans, true religion jeans, nike free, air max, coach purses, air max, michael kors outlet, gucci outlet, ray ban sunglasses, louis vuitton outlet, jordan shoes

October 28, 2014 at 2:02 AM  
Blogger oakleyses said...

abercrombie and fitch, nike roshe run, nike free pas cher, longchamp, mac cosmetics, hogan outlet, nike free, polo ralph lauren, sac burberry, michael kors pas cher, hollister, polo lacoste, nike tn, sac hermes, nike huarache, nike roshe, north face, sac longchamp, new balance pas cher, louis vuitton, vanessa bruno, longchamp, vans shoes, louis vuitton uk, air max, ray ban sunglasses, north face, nike blazer, nike roshe run, air jordan, sac guess, vans pas cher, barbour, oakley pas cher, nike air max, sac louis vuitton, lululemon, mulberry, michael kors, sac louis vuitton, ralph lauren, hollister, hollister, nike trainers, michael kors, ray ban pas cher, air force, converse pas cher, timberland, louboutin

October 28, 2014 at 2:02 AM  
Blogger oakleyses said...

lululemon outlet, mont blanc, air max, nfl jerseys, rolex watches, beats by dre, moncler, new balance shoes, bottega veneta, ugg, ugg australia, hollister clothing store, giuseppe zanotti, wedding dresses, iphone 6 cases, canada goose, ugg boots, ghd, reebok outlet, ferragamo shoes, chi flat iron, moncler, north face jackets, soccer shoes, ugg boots, abercrombie and fitch, babyliss pro, baseball bats, valentino shoes, uggs outlet, ugg pas cher, insanity workout, instyler, moncler outlet, canada goose uk, north face outlet, moncler, canada goose, marc jacobs, canada goose, herve leger, asics running shoes, canada goose jackets, birkin bag, canada goose outlet, soccer jerseys, p90x, jimmy choo outlet, mcm handbags, celine handbags

October 28, 2014 at 2:03 AM  
Blogger Lin Shijun said...

shijun 6.24
retro jordan
coach outlet store online
polo ralph lauren
michael kors uk
cheap oakley sunglasses
michael kors
jordan 3
jordan 11s
gucci handbags
kevin durant shoes 2015
oakley frogskins
true religion outlet
lebron james shoes 2015
louis vuitton handbags
abercrombie kids
louis vuitton
chanel purses
ghd flat iron
ray ban glasses
insanity workout
ray bans
michael kors outlet
ray ban wayfarer
air max shoes
michael kors
coach outlet store online
adidas wings
coach outlet
michael kors uk
coach factory online
ralph lauren uk
louis vuitton purses
true religion sale
chi hair strighteners
coach factory outlet
kate spade bags
coach outlet online
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors handbags
concord 11s

June 24, 2015 at 2:23 AM  
Blogger Xiaozhengm 520 said...

2015-9-14 xiaozhengm
Abercrombie Short T-Shirts
louis vuitton
Abercrombie and Fitch Striped Shirts
michael kors bags
Louis Vuitton Neverfull GM Monogram
Nike Lebron James Shoes For Sale
ugg boots sale
michael kors handbags
michael kors outlet
Hollister Shirts For Women
Michael Kors Outlet Official Website
Air Jordan 3 "Infrared 23"
toms outlet
michael kors uk
Discount Clearance Coach Outlet Handbags
ugg boots outlet
canada goose jackets
Toms Shoes Sale Clearance
uggs on sale
ugg boots on sale
tory burch sale
UK Louis Vuitton Handbag Outlet
Michael Kors Factory Outlet Online Official
burberry outlet
Christian Louboutin Outlet Authentic Sneakers Online
Outlet Michael Kors Online
Air Jordan 6 Cigar
Ray Ban Outlet Store Online
Louis Vuitton Outlet Factory Online

September 14, 2015 at 5:09 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home