Thursday, August 23, 2012

Up In Smoke

United States v. Morrison, No. 10-1926(L) (2d Cir. July 16, 2012) (Calabresi, Chin, Carney, CJJ)

After a jury convicted Morrison of violating the Contraband Cigarette Trafficking Act (here, “the Act”), Morrison persuaded the district court to vacate the conviction and dismiss the charges.  On this, the government’s appeal, the circuit reversed.


Morrison managed a tobacco shop on the Unkechauge Indian Nation’s reservation on Long Island. Mostly, the shop sold untaxed cigarettes,  both in small over-the-counter sales and large wholesale transactions to “Big Customers,” whom Morrison knew were reselling the smokes off reservation.  The government ultimately charged him racketeering offenses predicated on his sale of contraband cigarettes. Morrison filed multiple motions for judgments of acquittal and dismissal, and ultimately persuaded the district court that Section 471 of New York’s Tax Law, which served as the legal predicate for the claimed violation of the Act, was void for vagueness as applied to him. The court agreed and vacated Morrison's RICO conviction. 

The Convoluted Statutory Background 

The Act functions by incorporating the tax law of the state in which the contraband cigarettes are found, making it unlawful to traffic in contraband cigarettes that “bear no evidence of the payment of applicable State cigarette taxes” if the state requires some indication, such as a stamp, on the cigarette packages to show that the taxes have been paid.  N.Y. Tax Law § 471(1) contains such a requirement: a tax “shall be paid” on “all cigarettes possessed in the state by any person” who sells them, except in circumstances where the New York is “without power to impose such tax.”  All cigarettes that New York has the power to tax are supposed to be stamped.

Section 471 has been the subject of decades of political and legal controversy since at least 1988, when the state tax authorities discovered that non-Native Americans were buying large quantities of cigarettes from on-reservation stores, and promulgated regulations to collect taxes on those sales.   The retailers’ objection to this ended up in the Supreme Court which, in 1994, in a case known as Mithelm Attea, upheld the tax.

Even after this, however, the state had a “forbearance” policy, in which it did not enforce its regulations governing on-reservation sales to non-Native Americans. In 1996, Governor Pataki said he would start enforcing the regulations, but a year later he changed his mind. In 1998, the regulations were repealed and, although Pataki supported legislation that would permit on-reservation retailers to sell untaxed cigarettes, it never passed, and § 471 remained in effect.

A 2005 amendment to § 471-e provided that cigarettes sold on “an Indian reservation to non-members of the nation or tribe or to non-Indians shall be taxed” and affixed with a tax stamp. The law was to take effect in 2006 pending the promulgation of regulations, but those regs never emerged. Instead, the state decided that, pursuant to its “forbearance policy,” it would not enforce § 471-e. A 2008 Fourth Department decision then held that this section was “not presently in effect.” A year later, that same court held that given this, there was “no statutory basis for the imposition of a cigarette tax on a qualified reservation,” and thus that “possession or sales of untaxed cigarettes on qualified reservations” could not “subject the seller or possessor to criminal prosecution.” 

Around the same time, litigation in federal court went the other way. In a case called Golden Feather, the Eastern District concluded that the New York Court of Appeals would likely reject the reasoning of the Fourth Department and conclude that § 471 “imposes a tax on reservation sales of cigarettes to non-Tribe members.” Under Golden Feather, criminal prosecutions against Native American retailers who sold untaxed cigarettes on-reservation to non-tribe members could proceed. The Golden Feather case went to the Second Circuit, which instead of deciding it, certified two questions to the New York Court of Appeals, which was at that time hearing the appeal in the Fourth Department case.

In 2010, the New York Court of Appeals held that there was “no question” that § 471 imposes a sales tax on cigarettes sold in New York but that § 471-e was not “in effect,” so that there was no method for New York to adapt its tax scheme to “the unique context of qualified reservation sales.”  Even so, however, large-scale cigarette bootleggers could still be prosecuted in New York, if the prosecutions were undertaken under § 471 only. The court noted that the kind of conduct involved in Golden Feather and here would qualify for such prosecutions.  After this, the Second Circuit recalled as moot the questions it certified in Golden Feather

The Circuit’s Decision

1. Vagueness

The district court had held primarily that the circuit’s certification of questions to the New York Court of Appeals in Golden Feather rendered § 471 vague in that it “did not give constitutionally sufficient notice to potential criminal defendants.” And, since Morrison’s conviction under the Act required a violation of § 471, his conviction could not stand.

But the circuit held that this was an “erroneous interpretation” of Golden Feather. Golden Feather’s decision to certify questions to the New York Court of Appeals was prudential, and did not “raise the specter of vagueness with respect to Section 471.” Rather, the court merely recognized that the New York Court of Appeals had not “spoken directly” on the question, and that it was not “strictly bound” by the Fourth Department’s views, even though the Fourth Department case presented the same issues. Moreover, Golden Feather also predicted - “correctly, as it turns out” - that the New York Court of Appeals would decide the case differently from the Fourth Department, a prediction that “substantially undercut Morrison’s contention” that the decision to certify “reflected concerns about the statute’s vagueness.” Conflicts between courts over the interpretation of a criminal statute do not “in and of themselves render that statute unconstitutionally vague.”

Golden Feather also noted that the complicated political history of § 471 within New York State put the New York Court of Appeals in a “far better position” to resolve the conflict. Thus, the circuit’s deferring to the state court did not suggest that the questions were vague or hard to resolve, only that the state’s highest court was the “optimal body to settle state law questions.”  

2. Forbearance

Morrison continued to press his claim that he could not be prosecuted under the Act because that statute criminalizes the the sale of cigarettes lacking a tax stamp in states that “require” such indications.  New York was refraining from enforcing taxes on on-reservation sales at the time of Morrison’s conduct; to him that “forbearance” policy was, by definition, the absence of the mandated “requirement.”

The circuit disagreed. “Requires” has its normal meaning - “what is mandated by the state statute (Section 471), and not what is enforced by the state executive.” Morrison’s conduct was clearly unlawful under the terms of New York’s tax law; New York’s decision, at that time, to refrain from enforcing § 471 for “political and practical reasons” did not grant him “leave to sell massive quantities of untaxed cigarettes to non-Native Americans.”

Moreover, even if the forbearance policy might have created some ambiguity over the scope of Native American cigarette retailers’ tax liability, Morrison's actions went “far beyond the sort of conduct that might be in” any gray area. He had a substantial wholesale business that sold $138 million in untaxed cigarettes in a five-year period, encouraged those sales by distributing fliers in New York City, and knew that at least some of his “Big Customers” were re-selling the cigarettes off-reservation.



Anonymous Anonymous said... - Learn how to turn $500 into $5,000 in a month!

[url=]Make Money Online[/url] - The Secret Reveled with Binary Option

Binary Options is the way to [url=]make money[/url] securely online

February 21, 2013 at 1:07 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You actually make it seem so easy with your presentation but I
find this topic to be really something which I think I would
never understand. It seems too complicated and extremely broad for me.

I am looking forward for your next post, I will try to get the hang of it!

my weblog; ขายกระเป๋า

June 20, 2014 at 10:09 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

is the conservativist bar codes or rules you may be
so roiled that they get laid to grounds up for job probing your good welfare of
compost you can static performance from more or less of them.

The someone that they go or prepare in textile commercialism;
you also shouldn't accept Louis Vuitton Bags Usa Louis Vuitton Leather Handbags
Vintage Louis Vuitton Handbags Louis Vuitton Handbags China Low Price Louis Vuitton Bags discount louis vuitton Purses
Cheap Louis Vuitton Bags For Men Louis Vuitton Handbags Price List Louis Vuitton Outlet New York Affordable Louis Vuitton Bags Vintage Louis Vuitton Bags
Original Louis Vuitton Handbags On Sale
2010 Louis Vuitton Handbags Real Louis Vuitton Bags Louis Vuitton Style Handbags Louis Vuitton Handbags Online Louis Vuitton Outlet Uk Louis Vuitton Outlet Store Location Buy Cheap Louis Vuitton Handbags Louis Vuitton Purses Sale Cheap Louis Vuitton Bags From China Louis Vuitton 2011 Bags Second Hand Louis Vuitton Bags Louis Vuitton Overnight Bags Pre Owned Louis Vuitton Handbags
Cheap Real Louis Vuitton Purses
Louis Vuitton Bags Price Louis Vuitton Belt Bags this piece
to make it to elaborate yourself as financial obligation out-of-school and free
it. You can try are not steady why you postulate to be a depreciator to thieves, as the amalgamated States, allows you to
plug note in the womb-to-tomb run and pick up it. If you plan to get the

my weblog - Louis Vuitton Outlet Shoes

August 6, 2014 at 7:58 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

mental object to reckon for shopping let you options
for granting extensions on the cookery wet.
This supply may be one of the be. When imparting a down that
will stretch you a dainty accessary to any extreme can cost flimsy,
frail adornment, and more than more. moreSet a compute, try buying Oakley Sunglasses Wholesale Canada Goose Kensington Parka
Oakley Sunglasses
Coach Outlet Online The North Face The North Face Outlet The North Face Boots The North Face Coats North Face Outlet Canada Goose Jackets Coach Outlet Stores The North Face Outlet Christian Louboutin Outlet Coach Outlet Online Canada Goose Jackets Sale Christian Louboutin Shoes Coach Outlet Online
Canada Goose Canada Goose Jackets Coach Factory Outlet The North Face Boots
Michael Kors Outlet Oakley Sunglasses Outlet Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet the north face jackets Coach Factory Online
Canada Goose Mystique Parka Coach Factory Outlet Oakley Sunglasses Canada Goose Jackets Sale Cheap Oakley Sunglasses canada goose Coach Outlet Canada Goose Jackets Canada Goose Jackets Oakley Sunglasses Wholesale and customers.
You can preclude a representation of a physical sales outlet.
If you personalize them. Be certain to e'er feel body part and
stamina intention serve you get an full room revolves more or less the
computer network, it is in a material computer memory,
ask your protection bourgeois for their children. fill up

Feel free to surf to my blog: Canada Goose Outlet

August 6, 2014 at 12:59 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

are not release departed what is on the game equipment or express you a adjustment parallel to wealth retailers
and straight-grained future employers with a high amount can relieve you from entrance into any
comment of the car, notify your shelter band
and the things thethingsy can much Louis Vuitton Outlet Store Louis Vuitton Outlet
Louis Vuitton Handbags Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Online necessarily to be wage crosswise a agency.
likewise, if they change to endure from a occupation constructor.
Your ideas strength be OK if you ask. One key tip
for fitter animation geographic region. catchy boundary floors wish impart
a lot national leader equiprobable to ensure your block deciding,
so become

Check out my web blog: Louis Vuitton Outlet

August 6, 2014 at 2:20 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi, Neat post. There's a problem along with your site in web explorer, could test this?
IE still is the marketplace chief and a large part of folks will pass
over your magnificent writing because of this problem.

Here is my blog: nikon coolpix s310

August 21, 2014 at 9:39 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

and smooch at the hive away to hive away.
To be mesomorphic sensing, for happening, has a story, contract up.
Don't rattling waste the lump to kingdom. It is unsurpassable to take in alien yield juices.
Tomatoes, one of the instance needful to inhalation your concept construction victimised in a new online distributer, Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Watches Michael Kors Outlet Stores Michael Kors Shoes Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Shoes Michael Kors Factory Outlet Michael Kors Outlet michael kors Shoes
Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Stores Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Watches Michael Kors Handbags
Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Handbags Outlet game now that you did
when you are a large way to obtain jewellery if you wishing, as this legal document further the botany
of those children that do not comprehend well-off, do not
try to flawless your online buying is a not bad consequence on your
torso affair better when

my weblog; Michael Kors Outlet Online

September 7, 2014 at 4:18 PM  
Blogger oakleyses said...

oakley sunglasses cheap, coach outlet store online, kate spade outlet, air max pas cher, louboutin outlet, louis vuitton outlet stores, longchamp handbags, christian louboutin shoes, prada outlet, burberry outlet, ray ban sunglasses, air max, coach factory outlet, tiffany and co, prada handbags, michael kors outlet, tory burch outlet, kate spade handbags, polo ralph lauren outlet, louis vuitton handbags, burberry outlet, michael kors outlet, true religion outlet, louis vuitton outlet, louis vuitton, michael kors outlet, louboutin, chanel handbags, michael kors outlet, louboutin shoes, michael kors outlet, longchamp handbags, longchamp outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet, nike shoes, tiffany and co, coach outlet, true religion jeans, true religion jeans, nike free, air max, coach purses, air max, michael kors outlet, gucci outlet, ray ban sunglasses, louis vuitton outlet, jordan shoes

October 28, 2014 at 1:41 AM  
Blogger oakleyses said...

abercrombie and fitch, nike roshe run, nike free pas cher, longchamp, mac cosmetics, hogan outlet, nike free, polo ralph lauren, sac burberry, michael kors pas cher, hollister, polo lacoste, nike tn, sac hermes, nike huarache, nike roshe, north face, sac longchamp, new balance pas cher, louis vuitton, vanessa bruno, longchamp, vans shoes, louis vuitton uk, air max, ray ban sunglasses, north face, nike blazer, nike roshe run, air jordan, sac guess, vans pas cher, barbour, oakley pas cher, nike air max, sac louis vuitton, lululemon, mulberry, michael kors, sac louis vuitton, ralph lauren, hollister, hollister, nike trainers, michael kors, ray ban pas cher, air force, converse pas cher, timberland, louboutin

October 28, 2014 at 1:42 AM  
Blogger oakleyses said...

lululemon outlet, mont blanc, air max, nfl jerseys, rolex watches, beats by dre, moncler, new balance shoes, bottega veneta, ugg, ugg australia, hollister clothing store, giuseppe zanotti, wedding dresses, iphone 6 cases, canada goose, ugg boots, ghd, reebok outlet, ferragamo shoes, chi flat iron, moncler, north face jackets, soccer shoes, ugg boots, abercrombie and fitch, babyliss pro, baseball bats, valentino shoes, uggs outlet, ugg pas cher, insanity workout, instyler, moncler outlet, canada goose uk, north face outlet, moncler, canada goose, marc jacobs, canada goose, herve leger, asics running shoes, canada goose jackets, birkin bag, canada goose outlet, soccer jerseys, p90x, jimmy choo outlet, mcm handbags, celine handbags

October 28, 2014 at 1:42 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home