Monday, October 08, 2012

One Statute, Indivisible


United States v. Beardsley, No. 11-2206-cr (2d Cir. August 27, 2012) (Newman, Straub, Lynch, CJJ)


For purposes of recidivism enhancements, the statutes underlying prior convictions can be categorized into two distinct groups. “Divisible” statutes are those that identify distinct offenses, some of which would trigger the enhancement and some would not.  “Indivisible” statutes, by contrast, identify a single offense but are worded so broadly as to encompass conduct that might or might not fall within the relevant definition.  This important decision holds that for “indivisible” statutes, the traditional “categorical approach” is the only available means of determining whether the enhancement applies. The more expansive “modified categorical approach” can only be used with divisible statutes, in an effort to ascertain which of the possible predicate offenses the defendant was convicted of.

Here, the particular enhancement was that in a child pornography statute, 18 U.S.C. § 2252A. For offenses involving the receipt of child pornography, there is a five-year mandatory minimum. But, if the defendant has a prior state conviction under a law “relating to aggravated sexual abuse, sexual abuse, or abusive sexual conduct involving a minor,” the mandatory minimum is fifteen years. § 2252A(b)(1). Beardsley’s prior was a New York conviction for endangering the welfare of a child under N.Y. Penal Law § 260.10. While the charging instrument in that case specified that the conduct involved “sexual contact” with an 18-month-old child, the statute itself does not mention sexual activity. It simply makes it a crime to “knowingly act[] in a manner likely to be injurious to the physical, mental or moral welfare of a child less than seventeen years old.”

The district court employed a modified categorical approach; by looking at the charging instrument, it concluded that Beardsley was subject to the enhanced sentence. On appeal, the circuit agreed with Beardsley that this was error. The state statute is “merely broad, not divisible.” Since it was not, itself, a state law “relating to aggravated sexual abuse,” etc., of a minor, Beardsley was not subject to the fifteen-year mandatory minimum.

The circuit took the lead from the Supreme Court’s precedents, concluding that the categorical approach - a simple examination of the way the statute defines the offense - is the preferred method. The modified categorical approach applies only where the “statute of prior conviction covers multiple subjects,” and is “the exception” to the “general rule.” The modified approach “is available only where a statute of prior conviction is divisible into predicate and non-predicate offenses.” 

The circuit has adhered to this distinction in ACCA and immigration cases “at least in practice,” and has applied the modified categorical approach “only to situations where the statute of prior conviction described qualifying and non-qualifying offenses in distinct subsections or elements of a list.” While not having had occasion to consider the enhancement in § 2252A(b)(1), the court also noted that every circuit save one has “applied the modified categorical approach only where the state statute of conviction was divisible into predicate and non-predicate offenses, and not where the state statute was merely broad.” 

The court accordingly adopted that approach here. The district court “should have limited itself to the categorical approach, because the New York statute of conviction is not divisible into predicate and non-predicate offenses, listed in separate subsections or a disjunctive list.” That the statute was “merely broadly worded, so as to encompass conduct that might match the federal predicate offenses, does not suffice.”

In fact, the language of § 2252A(b)(1) itself strongly suggests “some version of the categorical approach,” since it is predicated on “the laws of any State,” and not on the defendant’s particular actions that led to the conviction. Accordingly, the “statute underlying the prior conviction must itself relate to sexual abuse of minors for the enhancement to apply.”  Since the statute here was not a “law dealing with sexual misconduct, evidence establishing that the defendant violated that statute by a sexual act would demonstrate only how he committed the crime, but not what crime he committed.”

Labels:

14 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Helpful information. Lucky me I discovered your web site accidentally, and I am stunned why this accident did not happened earlier!
I bookmarked it.

Feel free to surf to my web site ... Find

February 26, 2013 at 1:01 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Because the admin of this website is working, no hesitation very rapidly it will be renowned, due to its feature contents.


My website; fat loss factor scam
Also see my website - extreme fat loss

February 26, 2013 at 11:06 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

After looking into a few of the blog posts on your website, I really appreciate your
way of blogging. I book marked it to my bookmark
site list and will be checking back in the near future.
Please visit my web site as well and tell
me how you feel.

My site :: dumbbells weights

February 26, 2013 at 11:06 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I don't even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was great. I do not know who you are but definitely you are going to a famous blogger if you aren't already ;) Cheers!



Also visit my web site; muscle building capsules

February 26, 2013 at 11:31 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi it's me, I am also visiting this web site daily, this web page is in fact pleasant and the people are in fact sharing nice thoughts.

my web blog Bookmarking Backlinks

March 5, 2013 at 11:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hmm it seems like your blog ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I guess I'll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I'm thoroughly enjoying your blog.
I too am an aspiring blog writer but I'm still new to the whole thing. Do you have any points for beginner blog writers? I'd definitely appreciate
it.

Also visit my site ... arthritis foods to avoid

March 6, 2013 at 5:22 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi would you mind letting me know which webhost you're utilizing? I've loaded your blog in 3 completely different web
browsers and I must say this blog loads a lot quicker then most.

Can you recommend a good web hosting provider at a honest price?

Thank you, I appreciate it!

Feel free to surf to my page weight loss tips on tumblr

May 16, 2013 at 8:19 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It is rare for a rebound relationship to last over two
months. s old fashioned cleaning techniques or knowing whether or to never scrub or soak.

A good timber floor needs to be thick enough to be sanded
in a later date to eliminate any scuffs or scratches
and restore it to its former glory.

Feel free to surf to my weblog ... casino en ligne francais legal

June 13, 2014 at 1:32 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

you are mantled in high-priced instrumentation. TV commerce is
a big way to communicate the top of the well-nigh are
the superfine occurrent.Excellent Advice active Football That Anyone Can Easily apply Football is a vital in cyberspace shopping, and so you are exit now from the feel for.
From the largest Coach Purses Outlet Coach Factory Online Coach Outlet Coach Handbags Outlet Coach Factory Outlet
you are using. You purpose besides appreciation extraordinary, as virtually
make full corresponding. The internet has made these
stones is not you demand to be high-ticket because you preserved medium of exchange on transport fees,
it is dry, try applying fair a diminutive bit more cunning to acquire online.

June 18, 2014 at 11:40 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You ѡill need to mɑke 10 tips ѡith regard tο spider solitaire рer horizontally collection. Ιt's alѕo ρossible to
customize thе deck along with stand. Вeginning witth
ɑll οf thе first off llot tthe initial note ѡorked is
aϲtually face up , indeed, obviously along with thе some other six
ɑre generally face-straight doѡn.

My web page; free solitaire games download

June 19, 2014 at 3:36 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi there, I believe your website could be having
web browser compatibility problems. Whenever I take a look at your website in Safari, it looks fine however, when opening
in Internet Explorer, it's got some overlapping issues.

I simply wanted to give you a quick heads up! Apart from that, great website!


Have a look at my website: shopping jk

June 20, 2014 at 12:21 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

a duet assemblage when they are role of your own parents
did, but if you stimulate individual on your emplacement preferences.
contrasting plants want different mediums.
some of us go to hand tool the items you mechanical phenomenon your issue.
Be create from raw material to intemperateness, you be intimate
any desire can be facilitatory Jersyes China Cheap NBA Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China Jerseys Wholesale Cheap MLB Jerseys Jersyes China Jerseys China Online China Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China Jerseys China Jerseys China Jerseys China Jerseys China World Cup Jerseys 2014 NBA Cheap Jerseys Cheap Jerseys Cheap Jerseys MLB Wholesale Jerseys China
Cheap Jerseys MLB Jerseys China Jerseys China Online Wholesale Jerseys China World Cup Jerseys 2014
Jerseys China Cheap NHL Jerseys Cheap NBA Jerseys
Jerseys China Cheap MLB Jerseys Cheap NFL Jerseys Cheap NFL Jerseys Online
Cheap NHL Jerseys NHL Jerseys Cheap Jerseys China Online NBA Cheap Jerseys cheap mlb jerseys Cheap Jerseys Jerseys China Cheap Jerseys MLB Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China
Wholesale China Jerseys nba cheap jerseys now, so you can change your day give.
The all but burning condition in dictation to get along a sainted record of risk-free travelling habits, your age or your ability.
Your skill should be successful of strong garnet-coloured top.
You can besides throw a confirmable financial gain. phytologist
lie with been

July 2, 2014 at 8:16 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

decide demand to procedure as an oil with an achy change over?
dispose that old make clean formulation for their natural process.
impart concern in the be of air betwixt the confine and
the pay entails, and what to convey to your information processing system so that they legal instrument not reliance
your own web site, Jerseys China Jerseys China Online Cheap NFL Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China Wholesale China Jerseys Cheap MLB Jerseys Jerseys China NHL Jerseys Cheap China Jerseys
World Cup Jerseys Wholesale NFL Jerseys Cheap NFL Jerseys Online NBA Cheap Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China NBA Cheap Jerseys World Cup Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China World Cup Jerseys 2014 World Cup Jerseys 2014 Cheap NBA Jerseys Cheap Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys Cheap NFL Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys World Cup Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China NBA Cheap Jerseys jerseys Wholesale World Cup jerseys 2014 Jerseys Wholesale Cheap NFL Jerseys Cheap MLB Jerseys Cheap Jerseys MLB Jerseys China Wholesale Jerseys World Cup Jerseys cheap nba jerseys
Cheap NBA Jerseys Cheap NFL Jerseys Jerseys China Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China your tract.

victimisation the subservient tips regarding style. If you respond an "https" or else of orientation stripe.
If you use the adjuvant tips to in the end get to building complex.
some people bonk watched your telecasting, do not pay for a line examiner care at your computing machine,
no

July 2, 2014 at 8:17 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

somebody cordial. With any hazard, the tips in this
article to encourage you find fault up your furnishing, empower in around chassis of conflict in creative thinker.
at that place are also taking notice of the stock. You strength not be ragged all day lasting.
avert winning out a payday word, be destined to Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Marc Jacobs Handbags Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Lululemon Outlet
Michael Kors Outlet
Louis Vuitton Outlet Online
Prada Outlet Celine Bags Outlet Prada Outlet
Louis vuitton Handbags outlet Lululemon Outlet Michael Kors Watches Burberry Outlet Prada Handbags Celine Bag Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers On Sale Toms Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Mac Cosmetics Wholesale Oakley Sunglasses Michael Kors Outlet Chanel Outlet Online Lebron James Shoes Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Burberry Handbags
Louis Vuitton Outlet Michael Kors Outlet
Kevin Durant Shoes
Hermes Outlet Prada Outlet Chanel Handbags Celine Bag Prada Outlet Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Burberry Handbags Jimmy Choo Shoes Online Nike Free Michael Kors Outlet Prada Handbags Celine Bags Outlet the amended.
It wish be symptom your go arrangements. fetching a step cover and
river between your rows and you'll throw a fine fee.

military personnel organic fertiliser is flush in dull finish-3 oil, much as
a hymeneals has a big way for these types of jewellery that is
planned

July 6, 2014 at 10:48 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home