Monday, October 08, 2012

One Statute, Indivisible


United States v. Beardsley, No. 11-2206-cr (2d Cir. August 27, 2012) (Newman, Straub, Lynch, CJJ)


For purposes of recidivism enhancements, the statutes underlying prior convictions can be categorized into two distinct groups. “Divisible” statutes are those that identify distinct offenses, some of which would trigger the enhancement and some would not.  “Indivisible” statutes, by contrast, identify a single offense but are worded so broadly as to encompass conduct that might or might not fall within the relevant definition.  This important decision holds that for “indivisible” statutes, the traditional “categorical approach” is the only available means of determining whether the enhancement applies. The more expansive “modified categorical approach” can only be used with divisible statutes, in an effort to ascertain which of the possible predicate offenses the defendant was convicted of.

Here, the particular enhancement was that in a child pornography statute, 18 U.S.C. § 2252A. For offenses involving the receipt of child pornography, there is a five-year mandatory minimum. But, if the defendant has a prior state conviction under a law “relating to aggravated sexual abuse, sexual abuse, or abusive sexual conduct involving a minor,” the mandatory minimum is fifteen years. § 2252A(b)(1). Beardsley’s prior was a New York conviction for endangering the welfare of a child under N.Y. Penal Law § 260.10. While the charging instrument in that case specified that the conduct involved “sexual contact” with an 18-month-old child, the statute itself does not mention sexual activity. It simply makes it a crime to “knowingly act[] in a manner likely to be injurious to the physical, mental or moral welfare of a child less than seventeen years old.”

The district court employed a modified categorical approach; by looking at the charging instrument, it concluded that Beardsley was subject to the enhanced sentence. On appeal, the circuit agreed with Beardsley that this was error. The state statute is “merely broad, not divisible.” Since it was not, itself, a state law “relating to aggravated sexual abuse,” etc., of a minor, Beardsley was not subject to the fifteen-year mandatory minimum.

The circuit took the lead from the Supreme Court’s precedents, concluding that the categorical approach - a simple examination of the way the statute defines the offense - is the preferred method. The modified categorical approach applies only where the “statute of prior conviction covers multiple subjects,” and is “the exception” to the “general rule.” The modified approach “is available only where a statute of prior conviction is divisible into predicate and non-predicate offenses.” 

The circuit has adhered to this distinction in ACCA and immigration cases “at least in practice,” and has applied the modified categorical approach “only to situations where the statute of prior conviction described qualifying and non-qualifying offenses in distinct subsections or elements of a list.” While not having had occasion to consider the enhancement in § 2252A(b)(1), the court also noted that every circuit save one has “applied the modified categorical approach only where the state statute of conviction was divisible into predicate and non-predicate offenses, and not where the state statute was merely broad.” 

The court accordingly adopted that approach here. The district court “should have limited itself to the categorical approach, because the New York statute of conviction is not divisible into predicate and non-predicate offenses, listed in separate subsections or a disjunctive list.” That the statute was “merely broadly worded, so as to encompass conduct that might match the federal predicate offenses, does not suffice.”

In fact, the language of § 2252A(b)(1) itself strongly suggests “some version of the categorical approach,” since it is predicated on “the laws of any State,” and not on the defendant’s particular actions that led to the conviction. Accordingly, the “statute underlying the prior conviction must itself relate to sexual abuse of minors for the enhancement to apply.”  Since the statute here was not a “law dealing with sexual misconduct, evidence establishing that the defendant violated that statute by a sexual act would demonstrate only how he committed the crime, but not what crime he committed.”

Labels:

12 Comments:

Blogger rohit said...

happy new years eve 2016 pictures

happy new years eve 2016 quotes

happy new year shayari quotes


happy new year business greeting

happy new year funny greetings

happy new year greetings images


Merry Christmas message card

merry christmas message download

November 23, 2015 at 10:21 AM  
Blogger chenlina said...

chenlina20151202
gucci handbags
supra shoes
the north face outlet
abercrombie & fitch
louis vuitton purses
air max uk
hollister co
coach factory outlet
air max 90
louis vuitton handbags
ugg outlet
ray ban sunglasses
replica watches
michael kors outlet online
canada goose jackets
kids lebron shoes
coach outlet
fitflops
ugg sale
coach outlet store online
michael kors outlet clearance
cheap oakley sunglasses
canada goose jackets
louis vuitton handbags
ugg boots outlet
michael kors outlet stores
true religion outlet
louis vuitton outlet stores
jordan concords
beats by dre
coach factory outlet online
uggs sale
ugg boots on sale
polo ralph lauren
louis vuitton outlet
fitflops sale clearance
cheap uggs
uggs outlet
uggs outlet
ugg sale
as

December 2, 2015 at 1:22 AM  
Blogger Gaurav Jain said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

December 3, 2015 at 2:11 AM  
Blogger Gaurav Jain said...

Nice post Please have alook on this

new year 2016
happy new year 2016

December 3, 2015 at 2:12 AM  
Blogger Murray butar said...

Catering Jakarta unikasi Konsultan Pajak dengan Jasa Pemasaran satu Rental Mobil sama Video Editing lain Jasa Konsultan Pajak Simbolikinteraksionis Sewa Mobil Jakarta upaya http://birojasa.xyz untuk Jasa Pemasaran Online menggambarkan Snack Box cara http://jasatraining.xyz orang Jasa Akuntansi mengevaluasi Promosi Bisnis Online perilaku http://kursusonline.xyz mereka Rental Mobil Jakarta dengan Jasa Konsultasi Pemasaran membandingkannya Paket Pernikahan dengan Jasa Video Shooting perilaku Catering Jakarta lain. Konsultan Pajak Dalam Jasa Pemasaran kasus Rental Mobil reality Video Editing TV, Jasa Konsultan Pajak bagian Sewa Mobil Jakarta dar http://birojasa.xyz anorang Jasa Pemasaran Online orang Snack Box yang http://jasatraining.xyz nyaman Jasa Akuntansi dan Promosi Bisnis Online membuat http://kursusonline.xyz lingkungan Rental Mobil Jakarta tenang. Jasa Konsultasi Pemasaran Dan Paket Pernikahan bagi Jasa Video Shooting anda Catering Jakarta pergi Konsultan Pajak tidur Jasa Pemasaran di Rental Mobil setiap Video Editing malam Jasa Konsultan Pajak dinding-dinding Sewa Mobil Jakarta putih http://birojasa.xyz menakjubkan: Jasa Pemasaran Online

December 8, 2015 at 4:02 AM  
Blogger Murray butar said...

krim pemutih prdouk wajah unggulan Jika krim pemutih ketiak pintu produk kecantikan Anda kosmetik wajah aman tidak produk kecantikan wajah memiliki krim pemutih wajah herbal seperti pemutih kulit badan saluran, krim pemutih ergi jual baju wanita yang jual baju import akan grosir pakaian wanita memungkinkan grosi baju korea Anda tas import branded untukmengakses butik tas online semua tas branded acara Jual Rumah pada Rumah Alam Sutera jaringan Rumah Dijual Alam Sutera dengan Rumah Bintaro biaya Rumah Dijual Bintaro bulanan. Rumah BSD Kualitas Rumah Dijual BSD

December 8, 2015 at 4:02 AM  
Blogger Murray butar said...

streaming Rumah Gading Serpong jenis Rumah Dijual Gading Serpong situs Jual Apartemen biasanya jual apartemen aceh langsa kedudukan jual apartemen bali badung tertinggi. jual apartemen bali denpasar Hulu jual apartemen kota cilegon adalah jual apartemen banten serang pilihan jual apartemen tangerang lain, jual apartemen alam sutera yang jual apartemen bsd tangerang mengumpul jual rumah akan jual rumah banten waktu jual rumah kota cilegon untuk jual rumah serang menghapus jual rumah tangerang tanda jual rumah tangerang alam sutera pita jual rumah tangerang bsd adalah jual rumah tangerang gading serpong pasir Jasa Bangun Rumah tanda jasa bangun rumah

December 8, 2015 at 4:03 AM  
Anonymous pankaj said...

Happy new year 2016 wishes quotes for husband and wife for free
Happy new year 2016 wishes messages wallpapers hd
Happy new year 2016 wishes messages wallpapers

December 12, 2015 at 4:18 AM  
Blogger Gaurav Jain said...

Nice post Please have alook on this

New Year Images 2016
Happy New Year Quotes 2016
Happy New Year SMS 2016 images

December 19, 2015 at 11:28 AM  
Blogger 柯云 said...

2015-12-21keyun
ugg boots outlet
air max 95
michael kors bags
air jordans
air max 95
lebron james basketball shoes
michael kors outlet online sale
oakley outlet
louis vuitton outlet
ugg boots
polo ralph lauren
coach outlet
ugg boots
michael kors outlet
abercrombie clothing
hollister clothing
michael kors outlet
toms outlet
swarovski crystal
ugg outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
michael kors outlet
ugg outlet
louis vuitton outlet stores
cheap toms
ugg sale
coach outlet store online clearance
p90x
nike air huarache
nike free 5.0
ugg boots outlet
instyler
coach outlet
coach outlet
michael kors
louis vuitton handbags
coach outlet store online
louis vuitton handbags
ugg boots

December 21, 2015 at 12:12 AM  
Blogger Dushyant Mtf said...

New year

Merry christmas

Merry christmas red

Merry christmas greetings

December 22, 2015 at 6:17 AM  
Anonymous Yepi said...

You need to kill time, you need entertainment. Refer to our website. hope you get the most comfort.
Thanks you for sharing!
Yepi
Kizi
Friv
Friv Games

January 17, 2016 at 1:41 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home